Skip to main content

Timber Frames vs. Steel Frames

 


Timber vs. Steel    

    While the material to build your house is chosen mostly out of personal preference, there is no clear answer as to which material is best, timber or steel. There are a lot of things to take into consideration when picking between the two materials, it is not just about how it looks. Speed of construction, environmental impact, sustainability, cost, and your location are all good points to take into consideration. Here we will go through each point to help make your decision easier on you.

Speed of Construction:

    While both materials are assembled in a similar manner, timber can actually take a shorter time to put up due to steel needing more tools and labor to attach each element together. On top of this, timber frames can be put up by carpenters or even used in DIY situations, and it helps that most professionals have experience with wood more than metal. Steel will always need a steel fabricator to put your project together. 

Environmental Impact and Sustainability

    Using materials that are environmentally friendly and have less of an economical impact is crucial. It is no secret that timber relies on both forests and the destruction of natural environments to make room for more plantations, however, there are more businesses trying to help with the impact of timber framing. Some businesses will plant a tree for every tree the cut down. There is even a new side of the argument saying that if the need for timber increases, then the demand for more forests will also increase. This will benefit the environment in lowering CO2 levels in the air, and encourage ethical and sustainable use of our forests. There are many who will choose steel over timber for this reason exactly, but steel has its own impact on the environment. The process to make steel is is very energy intensive, which can create a huge carbon footprint that is damaging to the environment, although it is easily recyclable. 

Cost

    It is difficult to look at the cost comparatively as there are so many different variables that can be placed into one job, however, you can almost always guarantee that the timber frame will be more affordable than the steel frame because the cost of labor will not be as much. 

Your Location

    Many will not even think to look at their location when deciding between what material to build their home out of, but it does matter. Steel is strong and durable, but when built in a coastal area, the harsh weather and salty air can cause the steel to rust and corrode. While timber on the other hand will require protection from termites and other insects no matter where you are. This shouldn't put you off of timber though, because if done right, timber can last for hundreds of years. 

    Here at Hickory Circle we can guarantee that when you call us about a job, we will get the job done and we will get it done right. If you are interested in our services call us at (330)-763-1122 or send a fax to (330)-695-2368 so that we can get you a quote on the service you request. You can even email us at MW@HICKORYCIRCLE.com. We look forward to hearing from you and helping you build the home of your dreams. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Choosing the Correct Timber Species of Wood

            Congratulations on taking the first step into building your own timber home frame. You have a couple of critical decisions to make in the coming weeks. One of the most important is which species of wood your timber framer will use in the construction of your home. There are an abundance of options available, all with their owns strengths and weaknesses. This important decision may include you looking at the availability, sustainability, cost and suitability of the wood.  The most common types of wood species for timber framing are: white pine, red and white oak, Douglas Fir, hickory and cedar.  Availability       Depending on what part of the country you're in, will largely impact what materials are available to you. It is cost efficient to use local materials as the cost of transporting posts and beams across the country can rack up costs in a hurry. It's unlikely that the area you reside in won't have the type of wood species you desire. Species of trees grow

Advantages of Timber Frame Homes

If you're considering designing a new home soon, a timber frame structure could be the way to go! There are many advantages to using timber for your building that can help you make the choice of creating your home with a custom timber design from Hickory Circle Construction.  One obvious advantage to using timber for your home is the fact that it is a natural resource, one of the few that is used for building in our modern society. This means that it is non-toxic, safe to handle and also naturally ages with your design. Along with being natural, timber is more sustainable and environmentally friendly than many other building materials. Timber can be grown faster than it is used and in many places in which timber is harvested, the harvesters are then required to plant more trees in the same place to ensure the renewability of the building material.    Timber frame structures have other benefits as well, such as a decreased energy need for the home. Timber is a natural insulator a

Main Differences Between Timber Frame and Post & Beam

  Timber framing and Post and Beam framing are often thought to be the same by the average person, but they are really quite different when it comes down to the details. Both techniques leave the trademark look of fully exposed beams on the inside of the structure.   The main difference between timber framing vs post and beam framing is the way timbers are connected to each other.  Timber framing  uses mortise and tenon joinery along with wooden pegs whereas Post and Beam framing uses half-lap joinery with hidden fasteners, and oftentimes metal bracing. So what does mortise and tenon joinery mean? Let’s break it down. The mortise is the side of the wood with the hole in, the tenon is the side with what is called the tongue tenon on it. The tongue tenon is a section of wood that is cut to lock into the mortise side of the joint. After the joint has been put together, it will be glued, pinned, or wedged to lock it in place. It is one of the oldest, longest used joint methods.    Timber f